Lib Dems call for pension tax relief for the richest to come under scrutiny again

The following article by Mark Pack originally appeared on the Liberal Democrat Voice website:

Liberal Democrat pressure in the coalition government has already secured significant reductions in the tax breaks for the very richest. However, these tax breaks are still sufficiently generous that there is the scope for raising plenty more money without introducing punitive tax rates.

For example, restricting the tax relief on pension contributions to 20% (the standard rate for most people) rather than the current 40% for those earning over £100,000 would raise over £3.5 billion more each year. Last year, in a clear sign of the way in which senior Liberal Democrats are thinking, David Laws asked a series of Parliamentary questions fleshing out the details of what would be raised by different moves.

So it is no surprise that Danny Alexander has returned to the theme in the Daily Telegraph:

Danny Alexander, a Liberal Democrat Cabinet minister, says the better-off are receiving overly-generous tax relief when they invest money for their retirement.

Mr Alexander’s proposals would see tax relief halve from 40% to 20%. He also wants workers on the minimum wage, who earn up to £12,500 a year, to pay no income tax at all.

Mr Alexander claims that removing the higher-rate tax relief would save the Exchequer more than £7?billion and make the system fairer. Even restricted to those earning more than £100,000 the Treasury could save £3.6?billion.

“If you look at the amount of money that we spend on pensions tax relief, which is very significant, the majority of that money goes to paying tax relief at the higher rate,” Mr Alexander told The Daily Telegraph.

His remarks may open up a new dispute between the Tories and Lib Dems over tax. They are already at odds over Lib Dem calls to keep the 50p top rate of tax and introduce a “mansion tax” on high-value homes. George Osborne, the Chancellor, is expected to strongly resist any calls to scrap higher-rate tax relief.

Arguing for cutting pension tax breaks for the richest in order to fund income tax cuts for millions is both sensible economics and smart politics. Sensible economics – because the net effect does not undermine the struggle to cut the deficit and in fact is likely to cause an economic boost with the extra spending caused by the income tax cut greater than the reduction in spending caused by the tax rise. Sensible politics – because once again it puts the Liberal Democrats on the side of tax cuts for the millions whilst the Tories are on the side of the very richest.

* Mark Pack is Co-Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and writes a monthly newsletter about the Liberal Democrats.

Leave a Reply



Les Bonner

Photo of Les Bonner
67, The Ridgeway
Grimsby,
North East Lincolnshire
DN34 5PH
T: 01472 310855
E:

TWITTER

lesbonner

Government slashes cost of public sector estate by £287mn http://t.co/HelU3gZ1

26 minutes ago Reply

RT @cllrdaisybenson: Times: Govt (and therefore taxpayers) won't finish paying for rent, maintenance and utility bills of fire control...

56 minutes ago Reply

RT @cllrdaisybenson: Continued: 'The project was cancelled after problems with the IT system...consultants made up half the management...

2 hours ago Reply

RT @cllrdaisybenson: The Times reports UK taxpayers paying £1m a month on mothballed fire service control centres set up by Labour govt....

2 hours ago Reply

Police warn people of new 'Courier Scam' http://t.co/QBjeHDwi

2 hours ago Reply

Sensible decision from European Court on prisoner voting rights http://t.co/gFZRccLL

2 hours ago Reply

RT @mshapland: Labours economic plan in 2010 was to lose the General Election and have someone else carry the can for their incompetence...

2 hours ago Reply

RT @fusionyt: We've got some exciting acts competing in Young Talent 2012!! You can join them! Sign up to compete with your act......

3 hours ago Reply

RT @libdemvoice: Vince Cable: "The moral centre of gravity for the Coalition"- http://t.co/ViFFDRE0 < by @lordbonkers

3 hours ago Reply

Sensible decision from European Court on prisoner voting rights http://t.co/I8o5j3R7

3 hours ago Reply

Julian Huppert backs TV chef to ensure academies don't serve junk food http://t.co/HKUQAOwe

7 hours ago Reply

Support for supermarket watchdog welcomed http://t.co/hXLhj5oh

10 hours ago Reply

Tax credit claimants warned of scam emails http://t.co/6TczXE6K

11 hours ago Reply

Sport England announce new £8m Inclusive Sport fund http://t.co/yuSuq8ha

12 hours ago Reply

Wonga warned over aggressive debt collection http://t.co/WEAwIe8q

13 hours ago Reply

Julian Huppert backs TV chef to ensure academies don't serve junk food http://t.co/aaP1U3gg

14 hours ago Reply

Julian Huppert backs TV chef to ensure academies don't serve junk food http://t.co/kZzJtlv7

14 hours ago Reply

Next steps on collective purchasing for a better energy deal http://t.co/ITtDIDsY

15 hours ago Reply

Next steps on collective purchasing for a better energy deal http://t.co/yBDTWxHm

15 hours ago Reply

Government slashes cost of public sector estate by £287mn http://t.co/HelU3gZ1

17 hours ago Reply

Join the Lib Dem supporters network







Administration